Despite all the praise and support from your family and friends, it's still hard to see the good in your work when you know how much better it can be. When we are our own worst critics, it seems like there's nothing to do but call it quits and move on to something that comes a little more naturally.
You get compliments on your work and creativity all the time, but you know that it's not really that good. What's the point in trying if you're never going to improve?
— Sylvia Plath
That voice inside your head isn't actually a bully -- it's terrified of the very real possibility that you will fail, and it's doing whatever it can to keep you safe...
...but it doesn't have the whole story. Your inner critic literally believes that failure will lead to death and destruction, which is why its pull is so strong. It's not your job to cast it aside and push it down (that will only make it stronger). No, your job is to tell it a new story. Your fears are valid, but they're not all that matter in this adventure, and they don't get to dictate your choices. So, let's give your inner critic a few more insights that will help it feel secure.
The thing about being your own worst critic is it’s a mindset that seems impossible to abandon. When you know you could be better or do better, it almost feels like your moral duty to pursue that standard. But consider this: What makes the ideal version in your head “better”? Who makes the rules, the bar by which you’re judging yourself? What would change if you get to decide what “success” looks like, and it doesn’t have to have anything to do with the end result? What if you can be committed to excellence AND be proud of what brought you here, to this moment, in all of its imperfect glory? You don’t have to play perfectionism’s game anymore, my friend. Who you are, right now, is worth celebrating, no matter how “successful” your attempt was.
“Tough love” is steeped in tradition, but I’m calling BS on it. That’s because strict discipline usually involves some kind of shaming when you aren’t able to fall in line, and shame never leads to true, sustainable growth. Humans are, by nature, imperfect and ever-changing. Developing an ability to keep to a rigid regimen will eventually fail you -- because things change, all the time. Discipline leads to an unhealthy reliance on rigidity, but self-compassion leads to flexibility -- the true key to consistency and growth. The more you feel free to fail, wildly and with abandon, knowing that you will be ok and loved and safe, the more inspiration and progress will find you.
So, what happens when you do all the healthy things -- practice self-compassion, embrace imperfection, and fail wildly -- but you’re still disappointed with your lack of results? First, remember that creativity is about the process. Focusing on the end result will almost always lead to disappointment eventually. Second, remember that it’s ok to be disappointed when things don’t work out. Learning to tolerate disappointment and discomfort is actually your key to continuing on your journey. Let yourself be sad that you don’t love the thing that you made, and then turn your efforts to learning from it instead. Choosing creativity means knowing you won’t love everything you make -- and that’s ok, because it’s the process you crave, anyway.
My name is Kolbie, and before discovering the magic of watercolor, I was a proud (and miserable) capital "P" Perfectionist.
In 2016, I was working in the White House (dream job, anyone?) and felt like a complete fraud -- the weight of my perfectionism was slowly crushing my confidence. Kind of on a whim, I picked up calligraphy and watercolor, and now, five years later, my life has turned upside-down in the best way. I went from insecure political writer to confident author, artist, and online educator. I've helped thousands of people worldwide unlock the power of their creativity, and I'm not stopping yet.
BEFORE WE GET TOO FAR INTO THIS...
In order to really separate yourself from the commercial definition of “success,” you need to figure out what it means for you. Think about what matters most, what gives your life the highest value. If it involves praise from others (fame, fortune, admiration), you’re not digging deep enough. Think about what brings you the most peace and satisfaction, and use that feeling to build your own definition of a “successful” project. If you were on your deathbed tomorrow, would your life now fit that definition? What can you do to pursue this new definition of success?
Think about the last time you were your own worst critic. Now, imagine writing down those criticisms and giving them to your best friend. You would never, right? That’s because you know giving all that negative, shame-filled feedback will not lift up another human being, so why do you think it would work for you? In order to make the worst critic a little quieter, you need to fill your soul with self-compassion. Write yourself a few specific notes of encouragement, and leave them around the house or the office for you to find throughout the day. Hopefully, they’ll give you (and maybe a few others!) a little boost when you need it most.
Take out a recent piece that you didn’t particularly love, and instead of looking at it with a critical eye, look at it with a curious one. What did you learn from this project? What moments felt good to you? What moments didn’t feel good? What can you use from this project in the future, and what are you going to leave behind? Are there any nuggets of gold that could be the start of a new project? Use your findings to start something new.
Watercolor can help you slow down and discover a new story
I was a Perfectionist through and through until I discovered watercolor. Diving into a creative practice provided a gentle way to retrain my thoughts, create moments of wonder, and build a life-changing sense of confidence and self-compassion.
I can't do the work for you, but I can de-mystify the "how" behind watercolor so you can jump straight to using it to build a healthy creative mindset and more magical life.
SIGN ME UP!
For a limited time only, I'm giving you a discount on my small-but-mighty beginners watercolor course. Take 15% off
Exploring Watercolor 101: LITE with the code "MINDSET15"
need more creative resources?
Learn my landscape painting process step-by-step in this interview/tutorial convo with Becca of the Happy Ever Crafter.
Catch my convo with Elle Zimmerman where we talk perfectionism and creativity (and why they don't mix).
Learn from the queen of emotional resilience herself on why vulnerability is actually more powerful than you think.
Let's get personal
Need a dose of inspiration? Join my email list for insightful deep dives and exclusive tips & tricks on all things creativity and mindset.